Search ▸ Agenda item attachment
A SPECIAL MEETING OF THE CAMBRIDGE CITY COUNCIL’S CITY CLERK PRELIMINARY SCREENING COMMITTEE WAS HELD ON SEPTEMBER 9, 2025. THE COMMITTEE MOVED TO EXECUTIVE SESSION TO CONSIDER APPLICANTS FOR THE POSITION OF CITY CLERK, BECAUSE DOING SO IN OPEN SESSION WOULD HAVE DETRIMENTAL EFFECT IN OBTAINING QUALIFIED APPLICANTS.
1
MINUTES OF THE
CITY CLERK PRELIMINARY SCREENING COMMITTEE
Tuesday, September 9, 2025
COMMITTEE MEMBERS
Megan Bayer, City Solicitor
Raecia Catchings, Chief People Officer
Marc McGovern, Vice Mayor/City Councillor
Matt Nelson, Director of Administration and Operations, City Manager’s Office
Melissa Peters, Assistant City Manager, Community Development Department
Jivan Sobrinho-Wheeler, City Councillor
Mayor E. Denise Simmons
A Special Meeting of the Cambridge City Council’s City Clerk Preliminary Screening
Committee was held on Tuesday, September 9, 2025. The meeting was called to order AT
11:00A.M. by the Honorable Mayor E. Denise Simmons. Pursuant to Chapter 2 of the Acts of
2025, adopted by Massachusetts General Assembly and approved by the Governor, this public
meeting was hybrid, allowing participation via Zoom and in person.
At the request of the Mayor, Clerk of Committees Erwin called the roll.
Megan Bayer – Present
Raecia Catching – Absent
Vice Mayor McGovern – Present
Matt Nelson – Present
Melissa Peters – Present
Councillor Sobrinho-Wheeler – Present
Mayor Simmons – Present
Present – 6, Absent – 1. Quorum established.
Mayor Simmons read the Call of the meeting which explained that the Committee would be
moving to executive session to consider applicants for the position of City Clerk because doing
so in open session would have a detrimental effect in obtaining qualified applicants. Mayor
Simmons noted that the Committee would adjourn in executive session and not return to open
session. Also present in both open and executive session was Naomie Stephen, Executive
Assistant to the City Council.
Mayor Simmons recognized Vice Mayor McGovern who made a motion to move to
executive session.
Clerk of Committees Erwin called the roll.
Megan Bayer – Yes
Raecia Catchings – Absent
Vice Mayor McGovern – Yes
Matt Nelson – Yes
Melissa Peters – Yes
Councillor Sobrinho-Wheeler – Yes
2
Mayor Simmons – Yes
Yes – 6, No – 0, Absent – 1. Motion passed.
At the request of the Mayor, Clerk of Committees called the roll for executive session.
Megan Bayer – Present
Raecia Catching – Present
Vice Mayor McGovern – Present
Matt Nelson – Present
Melissa Peters – Present
Councillor Sobrinho-Wheeler – Present
Mayor Simmons – Present
Present – 7. Quorum established.
Naomie Stephen explained that there were eight candidates out of the one hundred and fifteen
applicants that would be reviewed today. Naomie Stephens shared that the eight candidates were
chosen because they met certain criteria and experience which was outlined in the job
description. Naomie Stephen explained that there were an additional twelve candidates with
related experience that could be considered if the Committee decided not to move forward with
the first eight. Naomie Stephen reviewed past practices of the preliminary Clerk search.
Vice Mayor McGovern shared that he would like to have three final candidates to be interviewed
by the full City Council after the first and second rounds of interviews. Committee members
discussed how long the first-round interviews should be for each candidate and shared
suggestions for the interview process. Mayor Simmons pointed out that it is important that all
candidates are asked the same questions in their interviews. The Committee agreed that they
would like to move forward with six out of the eight candidates for the first round of interviews.
Raecia Catchings highlighted the importance of having someone who will match well with
others in the City Clerk’s Office. Mayor Simmons shared suggestions on what she believes is
important to look at when reviewing candidates. Vice Mayor McGovern emphasized that it is
important for the new City Clerk to understand Robert’s Rules.
The Committee reviewed the eight applicants who met all the criteria and decided on candidates
to bring forward to the first round of interviews. The Committee then reviewed the twelve
applicants who met some of the criteria and decided not to move forward with any of them at this
time.
The Committee reviewed potential interview questions for the first and second round of
interviews. Naomie Stephen shared questions that have been used in past City Clerk interviews.
Committee members provided suggestions for possible questions that could be added or changed
to use different language. The Committee agreed on what questions to edit and remove.
Megan Bayer suggested increasing the interview time from thirty minutes to forty-five minutes,
so candidates do not feel rushed. The Committee agreed. Mayor Simmons asked if interview
questions would be shared with candidates in advance of the interview. Naomie Stephan
explained that they would not know in advance. Mayor Simmons suggested providing the
questions to the three finalists. Naomie Stephen added that in the past, a writing sample has been
3
requested from candidates and that she would review that process with the Committee at a later
time.
Naomie Stephen shared that she would be checking the references for the candidates moving
forward. Raecia Catchings explained what the next steps would look like moving forward within
the Human Resources Department.
The Committee reviewed possible dates for the first round of interviews and decided on
September 19, 2025 and September 24, 2025. Each day will consist of interviewing three
candidates.
Mayor Simmons recognized Councillor Sobrinho-Wheeler who made a motion to adjourn
the meeting.
Clerk of Committees Erwin called the roll.
Megan Bayer – Yes
Raecia Catchings – Yes
Vice Mayor McGovern – Yes
Matt Nelson – Yes
Melissa Peters – Yes
Councillor Sobrinho-Wheeler – Yes
Mayor Simmons – Yes
Yes – 7. Motion passed.
The meeting adjourned at approximately 12:10p.m.